What team bush doesnt want you to know 2002, context books, new york. And in the ceasefire of 1991 saddam agreed unconditionally to give up his weapons of mass destruction. Israeli report faults intelligence on iraq the new york times. Bush raised the specter of the iraqi pursuit of nuclear weapons as one justification for taking decisive action against iraq. Israeli report faults intelligence on iraq the new york. The subcommittee on israels intelligence agencies cited the same kinds of apparently inaccurate assessments on weapons of mass destruction. Bush did not lie about the presence of weapons of mass destruction to justify the iraq war, journalist bob woodward said sunday. Six months after the end of major hostilities, no weapons of mass destruction have been found in iraq. The nuclear arsenal j anes sentinel country assessment sentinel. Bush justified the war by claiming that saddam had weapons of mass destruction and had to be prevented from using them.
In this book, two experts from the region explore why the matter remains unresolved, and outline a comprehensive yet achievable roadmap to a. Feb 05, 2004 french president jacques chirac, in february 2003, spoke about the probable possession of weapons of mass destruction by an uncontrollable country, iraq, noting the international community is right. Much of what is known about israel s nuclear program comes from revelations in 1986 by mordechai vanunu, a technician at the negev nuclear research center who served an 18year prison sentence as a result. Every other country in the region seeking to make or obtain weapons of mass destruction awakens israels curiosity. There are weapons of mass destruction gone out from iraq to syria, and they must be found and returned to safe hands, mr. Much information about iraqs weapons of mass destruction is already in the public domain. Most importantly, the iraqi case suggests that such operations cannot be used in a. Today, estimates of the israeli nuclear arsenal range from a minimum of 200 to a maximum of about 500. Jun 30, 2018 the israeli arsenal of weapons of mass destruction clearly dwarfs the actual or potential arsenals of all other middle eastern states combined, and is vastly greater than any conceivable need for deterrence. By 1981, the reactor was on the verge of becoming hot, and israeli prime minister.
The greatest threat iraq, weapons of mass destruction. Seyed hossein mousavian is a middle east security and nuclear policy specialist at the program on science and global security. How the press that sold the iraq war got away with. The insider israel provided wmd evdience against iraq. Iraq actively researched and later employed weapons of mass destruction wmd from 1962 to. Excerpted from hegemony or survival, metropolitan books, 2004 paperback edition. Mar 01, 2002 possessing chemical and biological weapons, an extremely sophisticated nuclear arsenal, and an aggressive strategy for their actual use, israel provides the major regional impetus for the development of weapons of mass destruction and represents an acute threat to peace and stability in the middle east. Mar 18, 20 in the course of the discussion, habbush told the mi6 officer that iraq had no weapons of mass destruction. Israel knew iraq had no wmd, says mp politics the guardian. Syria and weapons of mass destruction center for strategic.
For patriots like billy sinclair, the iraq war started o. The failure to find weapons of mass destruction in iraq has led to a close scrutiny of the role of intelligence agencies in both the united states and britain. Jan 24, 2002 in recent weeks, the iraqi media have reported several times on the issue of weapons of mass destruction wmd. For example, the possession of weapons of mass destruction can be a powerful lever to maintain the status quo, or to influence events to israel s perceived advantage, such as to protect the so called moderate arab states from internal insurrection, or to intervene in interarab warfare. Israel s weapons of mass destruction much direct and indirect evidence shows clearly that israel is in possession of a large nuclear arsenal, together with chemical and biological weapons, and the means of delivering them over long distances.
Shlomo brom, points out, israeli intelligence, which was in full agreement with american and british intelligence estimates, has, however, remained in the shadows. According to the duelfer report the final report on iraqs weapons of mass destruction by the pentagon and cia organized iraq survey group iraq had no deployable weapons of mass destruction on the eve of the u. As america issues dire warnings about iran, many elements resemble the leadup to the 2003 iraq war, not least among them the israel factor. Israel is widely believed to possess weapons of mass destruction, and to be one of four nucleararmed countries not recognized as a nuclear weapons state by the nonproliferation treaty npt. Global nonproliferation regimes and regional experiences, eds. Setting the record straight 2005, by project for the new american century pdf at wayback machine iraq s weapons of mass destruction programs 2002, by united states central intelligence agency html and pdf at cia. In case iraq does have the ability to launch a missile attack, israel is far more capable of defending itself than it was in 1991. Cia, iraqs weapons of mass destruction programs, october 2002, unclassified. In the thenclassified national security directive 54, signed on january 15, 1991. Iraq and weapons of mass destruction wikimili, the best. Requirements and constraints, in building a weapons of mass destruction free zone in the middle east. It shows that iraq has refurbished sites formerly associated with the production of chemical and biological agents.
In the end, if the israeli intelligence knew that iraq did not have weapons of mass destruction, so the cia knew it and thus british intelligence. These are irresponsible states, which must be disarmed of weapons mass destruction, and a successful american move in iraq as a model will make that easier to achieve, sharon said to a visiting delegation of american congressmen. Iraq and weapons of mass destruction the national security archive. Parliamentary investigators have determined that israel s intelligence services delivered an erroneous assessment of prewar iraq s weapons of mass destruction, an israeli newspaper reported thursday. The establishment of a middle east zone free of nuclear weapons, a concept more recently broadened to cover all weapons of mass destruction wmd, has been before the international community for decades. The us congress office of technology assessment has recorded israel as a country generally reported as having undeclared chemical warfare capabilities, and an offensive biological warfare program. Between 1991 and 2003 politics was saddams weapon of mass destruction. Iraq actively researched and later employed weapons of mass destruction wmd from 1962 to 1991, when it destroyed its chemical weapons stockpile and halted its biological and nuclear weapon programs as required by the united nations security council. Six months after that congressional hearing, the united states invaded iraq in march 2003 and overthrew saddams regime.
The attached two reports look beyond the narrow issue of nuclear weapons, and summarize developments in each countrys full range of weapons of mass destruction including chemical and biological weapons and delivery systems. Israel accused over dud saddam reports the independent. The book plays out chronologically, beginning with a history of nuclear proliferation during the cold war. The fifth president of iraq, saddam hussein, was internationally condemned for his use of chemical weapons during the 1980s campaign against. Iraq s history with chemical, biological and nuclear weapons commonly referred to as weapons of mass destruction wmd is a story of development, war, deception and surprise. Sharons government, has alleged that israel knew iraq had no weapons of mass destruction, but did not tell the united states because israel.
Israel was a full partner in the intelligence failures that led to the conclusion that iraq possessed weapons of mass destruction before the. The resort to force, by noam chomsky excerpted from hegemony. Egypt, iran, iraq, israel, libya, and syria all have significant capabilities to deliver weapons of mass destruction. Iraqs history with chemical, biological and nuclear weapons commonly referred to as weapons of mass destruction wmd is a story of development, war, deception and surprise. This points clearly to iraqs continuing possession, after 1991, of chemical and biological agents and weapons produced before the gulf war. The argument has been used for years by democrats and other detractors, but woodward said on fox news sunday that his own 18month investigation showed that bush was actually skeptical. Iraq, weapons of mass destruction, and the crisis of global. Dec, 2016 for bureaucratic reasons we settled on one issue, weapons of mass destruction, because it was the one reason everyone could agree on, thendeputy defense secretary paul wolfowitz told vanity. During its last three years of operation, unscom was unable to detect any evidence that iraq had been further concealing prohibited weapons, even though the scope of inspections had expanded. At a time when tv screens are filled with images of perceived weapons of mass destruction wmd in iraq among people who are on the verge of starvation, the west turns a blind eye to the first biological terrorist in the middle east, israel, where the largest depot of wmd between london and peking is located. Iraqs internal documents not only demonstrate the details of its fairly successful influence operations in the 1990s, they also highlight the limitations of such operations. I asked lord butler if his inquiry had been aware of the meeting and of what habbush had.
If butlers understanding of israel s defence posture during the gulf war is accurate then the reader can take it that if saddam were to use a chemical weapon or worse against a city like tel aviv then almost certainly and without consultation israel would respond with tactical nuclear weapons against iraq. The central focus of iraq news is the tension between the considerable, proscribed wmd capabilities that iraq is. Nov 16, 2008 iraq s weapons of mass destruction tanabear911. Oct 16, 2000 the middle east is the scene of an ongoing process of proliferation.
Israel has not signed the nonproliferation treaty npt, but supports establishment of a middle east zone free of weapons of mass destruction. Israel also possesses a comprehensive arsenal of chemical and biological weapons. Indeed, egypt employed chemical weapons in yemen during the civil war there in the 1960s. A leftist lawmaker, yossi sarid, a sharp critic of mr. Israel also keeps track of other countries, often geographically remote, that are potential suppliers of weapons of mass. Israeli intelligence was a full partner with the us and britain in developing a false picture of saddam husseins weapons of mass destruction capability, said the author of the report, retired brigadier general shlomo brom. Israel very concerned about iraq iraq news, july 15, 1999 by laurie mylroie. Sadas comments come just more than a month after israel s top general during operation iraqi freedom, moshe yaalon, told the sun that saddam transferred the chemical. Both iraq and iran made substantial use of these weapons during the 19801988 iraq iran war. Richard butler, career diplomat from down under, authored this book in 2000 about his experiences fighting for nuclear disarmament, nonproliferation, and then as the head of the unscom weapons inspection program in iraq during the 1990s. He is a former diplomat who served as irans ambassador to germany 19901997, head of the foreign relations committee of irans national security council 19972005, spokesman for iran in its nuclear negotiations with the international community 20032005.
Feb 04, 2004 it was known in israel that the story that weapons of mass destruction could be activated in 45 minutes was an old wives tale, yossi sarid, a member of the foreign affairs and defence committee. Iraq, weapons of mass destruction, and the crisis of global security richard butler on. Iraq, israel, and the jews by zunes, stephen tikkun, vol. Following the gulf war, iraq had to admit to all this. Here are the similarities and big differences as america issues dire warnings about iran. Much information about iraqs weapons of mass destruction is already in the. Jun 03, 2008 both israel and syria have long been involved in creating weapons of mass destruction and the means to deliver them. Between iraq s invasion of kuwait in august 1990, and the commencement of military action in january 1991, then president george h. Israeli and syrian weapons of mass destruction center for. Iraq, weapons of mass destruction, and the crisis of global security. It was known in israel that the story that weapons of mass destruction could be activated in 45 minutes was an old wives tale, yossi sarid, a member of the foreign affairs and defence committee. So when france sold iraq a topoftheline nuclear reactor in 1975, the israelis were justifiably.
Israels weapons of mass destruction the day america was punked. Greece and turkey, as well as all iraqs gulf neighbours and israel 0. Israels nuclear arsenal and weapons of mass destruction. Mar 28, 2004 a leftist lawmaker, yossi sarid, a sharp critic of mr. Some of these reports insisted that iraq had no such weapons, citing as proof the renewed international atomic energyagency inspectors visits, while others focused on iraqi efforts to obtain these weapons, and its right to them. Unimaginable destruction if israel did attack iran with.
Whatever the number, there is little doubt that israeli nukes are among the worlds most sophisticated, largely designed for war fighting in the middle east. Israels weapons of mass destruction much direct and indirect evidence shows clearly that israel is in possession of a large nuclear arsenal, together with chemical and biological weapons, and the means of delivering them over long distances. Wmd and cooperate with terrorists, the official pretexts for invading iraq. Jan 01, 2004 the war in iraq has brought into sharp focus the problem of weapons of mass destruction wmd in the middle easta problem that is by no means new to the region. Iraq invades iran, beginning a war that ends in stalemate eight years later. If butlers understanding of israel s defence posture during the gulf war is accurate then. If butlers understanding of israels defence posture during the gulf war is.
Prime minister ariel sharon said yesterday that iran, libya and syria should be stripped of weapons of mass destruction after iraq. May 12, 20 unimaginable destruction if israel did attack iran with nuclear weapons by may 12, 20 may, 20 written by nick turse may 12, 20 may, 20. A staple of the israeli nuclear arsenal are neutron bombs, miniaturized. Israel and weapons of mass destruction after the iraq war.
1122 1040 1020 1169 739 844 979 1435 269 213 1087 1129 1354 430 1494 94 1407 1511 1220 1432 800 1291 695 248 1166 5 11 57 265 1218 1202 1264 18 3 64